Broken Link, Broken Trust
This week’s fix is about a transactional email with one clear job: help the customer track their order.
The email looked fine, the message was clear, and the CTA made sense.
But when I clicked Track Delivery, the link went nowhere.
And when the link breaks, the email breaks.

So, I recently got an order email after buying a Macbook through Aeroplan (needed a new one after 7 glorious years on my last one).
Pretty normal email. It confirmed the order, told me the delivery was being handled through UPS, and gave me a clear Track Delivery button. Great.
Except the button didn’t actually take me to a tracking page…
The hyperlink looked like it was set to something incomplete, basically just /ups/ instead of a real tracking URL.
That might sound like a tiny mistake, but in this type of email, it matters.
This was not a promo email where someone might casually browse, this was a transactional email. The customer has a very specific question:
Where is my order?
If the tracking link doesn’t work, the email fails the exact moment it’s supposed to be useful.

What Probably Went Wrong
This kind of mistake usually isn’t a copy problem, it’s a system problem.
A few things may have happened:
- The tracking URL field didn’t populate properly;
- The email pulled in the carrier name but not the full tracking link;
- The button link was not checked in the final email;
- There was no fallback if the tracking URL was missing;
- The QA process focused on how the email looked, not what the email did.
That last one is the big one. A lot of emails get approved because they look right, but looking right is not the same as working right.
Why It Matters
A broken link in a transactional email does more damage than people think! It creates friction, it creates support tickets, it makes the customer question where the order, tracking or company process is reliable.
And worst of all, it breaks trust at a high-intent moment.
The customer is not asking to be marketed to, they’re asking for help completing the next step.
That is why transactional emails need to be treated like part of the customer experience, not just automated receipts.

The Fix
Before sending order, shipping, booking, receipt, account or onboarding emails, test the actual customer journey, not just the template. The real version.
That means checking the following:
- Does the CTA go to the right destination?
- Does the tracking link work?
- Does the order ID populate?
- Do all merge tags have fallback logic?
- Can the customer complete the next step without contacting support?
The rule is simple: never approve an email because it looks right. Approve it because it works.
The Better System
For transactional and lifecycle emails, I’d use a simple QA flow before anything goes live.
- Test the Template: Make sure the layout, copy, branding, buttons and mobile rendering look right;
- Test with Real Data: Use actual or realistic order data, customer data, tracking data, account data or product data;
- Test the Fallback State: Ask yourself… what happens if the first name, tracking URL, product image, order number or account link is missing?
- Click Every Link: Buttons, text links, image links, logo links, footer links, unsubscribe links. All of them.
- Check the Job of the Email: Can the customer do the thing this email is asking them to do? If the answer is no, the email is not ready.
Takeaway
A broken tracking link is not just a broken tracking link, it’s a broken customer moment. That’s where a lot of email problems hide.
Not in the design.
Not in the subject line.
Not even in the copy.
They hide in the gap between what the email promises and what the customer can actually do next!
On Thursday, we’ll go into the system behind the fix: how to test the real customer journey before sending so broken links, missing data and failed CTAs don’t slip through.
Want a second set of eyes on your emails?
Plotnicki helps teams fix broken campaigns, lifecycle gaps, newsletters and email systems that should be working harder.
Reply to this email or click the link below so we can take a look.